Liberation Is the Answer

headshot Bana Zuluf woman with long dark hair against graphic background

This essay is published as part of a series emerging from a workshop convened by the Future of Peace program at the World Peace Foundation. Bringing different approaches to peace and futures thinking into conversation, the workshop explored a central question: How can different ways of engaging the future expand the possibilities for peace across different scales of social and political change? Explore the full series of essays and the accompanying synthesis as they are published on Reinventing Peace.


The real tragedy is that most people in the world are trapped between the horror of a putative peace and the terror of war. Those are the two sheer cliffs we’re hemmed in by. The question is: How do we climb out of this crevasse?—Arundhati Roy[1]

First and foremost, and before I attempt to answer the question of peace futurity, I would like to begin from my position as a Palestinian who views Palestine as the lens in which I understand the world. In doing so, my methodology is strictly decolonial, imaginative and politically reflexive. Palestine and its story of resilience, resistance and recalcitrance in the face of genocidal settler colonialism inspired students, workers, and ordinary people around the globe. This continuous and ongoing collective struggle for freedom in Palestine has transgressed the river to the sea boundaries to become the struggle of all people everywhere against the US backed zionist entity. From this transnational framing, I attempt to respond to the question of peace as a member of the wretched of the earth as it holds a very different meaning to the normative understanding of peace.

Against the backdrop of an ongoing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, the language of “peace” has once again assumed a central position in international responses to Palestine. The most recent example is the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2803, which established the Board of Peace (headed by the US President Trump, including Israel as a member) as a transitional administration for Gaza under the Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict. Yet again, a population subjected to genocidal violence is presented with another artificially constructed architecture of “peace”, administered through institutions whose authority rests largely outside the population whose future they seek to organize.

This latest iteration belongs to a longer history of peacebuilding interventions in and on Palestine. The language of peace in Palestine has appeared as a backdrop to successive massacres, dispossession, settlement expansion, occupation and the prolonged obstruction of Palestinian self-determination since before the 1947 UN partition Plan which entrenched Israel’s colonial “right to dominate” borrowing from Nicola Perugini and Neve Gordon.[2] In 2024, the International Court of Justice found that Israel’s settlement policies and annexation of parts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory obstruct the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination and concluded that Israel must cease all settlement activity.[3] However, the ruling did not address (yet again) the Palestinian right of return and freedom of the Palestinian people.

The problem, therefore, does not lie in a shortage of “peace” discourse. Palestine has experienced an abundance of it. Oslo, successive diplomatic peace processes, peace organisations, peace invitations, dialogue initiatives and people-to-people projects have all promised movement towards resolution. Perhaps with enough constructive ambiguity [4]to keep hope alive for Palestinian people. The material history against which these initiatives developed tells another story. The persistence of peacebuilding alongside Palestinian dispossession forces us to ask: whose peace?

Taking this question seriously requires what Brendan Ciarán Browne has described as the need for a “long gaze”.[5] The long gaze requires us to discern the conditions of the past and the present, while refusing to limit the future to these conditions. Such an approach engages the future by refusing to treat the present distribution of power as its necessary foundation. For Palestine, the futurity of peace, therefore, requires more than the cessation of immediate violence, nor does it resemble formal solutions of statehood. It requires peace on the terms of the oppressed. A peace that Palestinians organize around liberation, justice, self-determination and return. Most importantly, the long gaze requires us to interrogate the presumption of innocence of peace and peacebuilding.

As Kwame Ture clarifies:

There is a difference between peace and liberation, is there not? You can have injustice and have peace. You can have peace and be enslaved. So peace is not the answer. Liberation is the answer.[6]

Historically, calls for peace by Western powerful institutions have (discursively and materially) demanded collective amnesia from the colonised. A prime example is a Trump speech at the White House in 2020:

Reciting past narratives about the conflict is unproductive. In order to resolve this conflict, the solution must be forward-looking and dedicated to the improvement of security and quality of life, while being respectful of the historic and religious significance of the region to its peoples.[7]

When we begin to imagine what peace on the terms of the oppressed looks like, we must avoid repeating those insidious attempts to deny historical injustice while dressing it as a concern for a colonial peace at the expense of the oppressed. As such, the future of peace refuses to deny the historical and political underpinnings of its absence in the past. If there was no peace, we must ask why that is and who is disturbing it and for what interest. In other words, there is no future of peace, in the geopolitical (or ontological) sense, without accountability.

Peace, normalization and the status quo

Engaging the future of peace first requires a reformulation of what peace means. At a global scale, this involves understanding peace through the respect for sovereignty of the Global South and through an end to the imperial relationships that continue to structure global economic and political life. Kwame Nkrumah notes the relationship between peace and domination: “the danger to world peace springs not from the action of those who seek to end neo-colonialism but from the inaction of those who allow it to continue.”[8]

Nkrumah challenges a familiar colonial logic that resistance represents the primary disruption to an otherwise peaceful order. Instead, he contends, the order that produces and maintains domination is and will always be the source of global instability. Peace, understood in this way, is at stark contradiction with colonialism, neocolonialism and systems of oppression today.

Maria-Louise Clausen’s concept of “violent peacemaking” provides an important framework for this problem.[9] Clausen argues that violence forms a constitutive element of today’s peacemaking interventions rather than an external aberration that appears when peacebuilding fails. She directs attention towards the ways peacebuilding interventions enact, conceal and legitimise violence whilst operating under the banner of peace. This analysis extends beyond conventional liberal peacebuilding. Economic peace, peace through strength and other models differ in their instruments, yet each requires scrutiny of the forms of violence normalised as attempts at peacebuilding.

I theorise the contemporary operation of “peace” through three related mechanisms: normalization, peacewashing and atomization.

First, peacebuilding approaches applied by Western institutions to asymmetric or neo/colonial contexts in the Global South often normalize managing injustice into an acceptable political condition. This mechanism ensures that the decline of direct or spectacular violence acquires disproportionate significance whilst slower forms of violence persist against the weaker party. Western institutional attempts at peacemaking then become the normalization of injustice through the acceleration of sporadic and paradoxical measures of humanitarian relief on the one hand and acquiescence to the violent status quo on the other. As such, the tempo of violence continuously changes whilst remaining visible and perpetual for the oppressed. This intentional attempt to draw ambiguity on the violent status quo by external peacebuilding experts working in and on the Global South, is a strategic tool of political gaslighting to shape and reshape the meaning of peace against the demands, rights and aspirations of decolonial peace on the terms of the oppressed.

The second mechanism, peacewashing, utilises peace as a concealment of violent structures. Once governments, institutions or projects describe an intervention as peacebuilding, reconciliation, dialogue or stabilisation, the terminology itself begins to confer political legitimacy. Instead of understanding peace in its material effects on structures of domination, peace language acquires political effects of its own (peace as a caricature in and of itself) as it flattens and distorts domination and makes existing colonial structures and dynamics appear compatible with peaceful resolution. An example is the inclusion of Israel, the perpetrator of genocide in Gaza, on the Board of Peace for Gaza.

The third and last mechanism of post Gaza genocide peacemaking is atomization. Atomization occurs through the separation of those prepared to inhabit imperial peace from those who refuse it. As Lal Fernando and Slabodsky write, “Peaceful coexistence among diverse communities is defined against those who resist asymmetrical power relations.”[10] As such, those who resist imperial peace attempt to disrupt the power imbalances while the “heroes of peace are forged locally even sanitizing the legacy of radical proposals so as not to upset the power imbalances.”[11] Those administering or accepting the settlement occupy the position of reasonable actors while those continuing to demand liberation become the spoilers, extremists or sources of instability. As such, Peace discourse breaks political solidarities whilst isolating those who reject the terms through which injustice continues to be normalized.

Together these processes produce a form of victor’s peace.[12] Much like victor’s justice, it universalises the preferences of those who possess the power to define peace. Roy asks:

What does peace mean to the poor who are being actively robbed of their resources and for whom everyday life is a grim battle for water, shelter, survival, and above all, some semblance of dignity? For them, peace is war. [13]

From safe spaces to a safe world

To remain hopeful, in the words of Gramsci’s “optimism of the will”,[14] we must remember that globally, the world struggled to preserve the dignity of Palestinians enduring genocide and settler colonialism. However, peacebuilding interventions and humanitarian practices and advocacy have yet to discern the full struggle ahead of us. We need greater honesty about the scale of transformation that peacebuilding work claims globally. At times, this transformation may be true for individuals or small pockets of social life such as helping people survive, recover, communicate, access support or experience temporary safety but it often neglects the core dysfunction of the system.

The language of “safe spaces” illustrates one example of this limitation. Safe spaces provide protection and relief for people living in conditions that remain unsafe. Their existence, therefore, responds to an immediate need, but such needs are perpetual as long as the threat remains.  The objective goal for us is to build a safe world rather than an expanding collection of protected pockets within a violent one.

Our work, thus, needs to connect scales. On the one hand, individual care is necessary, but it belongs alongside community organisation and structural transformation. On the other hand, community work is also necessary, but it must build collective political consciousness of the institutions re/producing harm. As such, institutional change is insufficient when global political and economic relations continually reproduce domination with impunity. The problem lies neither with care nor with immediate relief; it lies in substituting them for holistic transformation. As such, a slower form of violence cannot become a measure of success. Slow violence is violence, nonetheless. Our definitions of decolonial peace must not reproduce the necropolitics of today’s victor’s peace.

Epistemic justice and liberatory futures

A liberatory future also requires epistemic justice. At times, the articulation of “imperial” peace ignores the definitions of peace by the colonised. Miranda Fricker frames this as “testimonial injustice” where “attributions of insincerity, irrationality, and incompetence have less to do with the speaker’s capacities than they do with identity prejudice in the hearer.”[15] The primary example is Palestine where throughout Palestinian history with zionist colonisation, testimonial injustice became a recurring theme. For instance, despite the vivid portrayal of the Nakba’s harrowing chapters, replete with massacres and horror, Palestinian credibility stood in perpetual scrutiny, awaiting validation from Jewish testimonies to be deemed worthy of acknowledgment. As such, the future of peace needs to be defined by the direct victims of its absence.

The future can expand the possibilities for peace when the oppressed acquire authority to define peace for themselves. This requires more than consultation with the oppressed. For example, Palestinian conceptions of justice, liberation, self-determination and return belong within the definition of peace rather than as debated demands. The same principle extends across the Global South. The application of one-size-fits-all[16] formula dressed as peacebuilding intervention ignores the political sovereignty of the Global South. Here the long gaze is crucial as existing geopolitical power relations constantly present themselves as the limits of political realism. A liberatory engagement with the future rejects this temporal and imaginative limitation. We must refuse to make today’s exploitative structures the permanent boundaries of tomorrow’s peace.

Conclusion

The work of peacebuilding often places us in an immediate dilemma. We recognise institutional harm, but we respond by trying to reduce suffering. There is no virtue in allowing people to suffer for the sake of theoretical consistency. But the distinction between preserving people and preserving the system needs serious consideration.

The image of a sinking ship visually captures this dilemma as we often find ourselves paddling because people remain on board and because stopping appears to place them in greater danger. We paddle harder as conditions deteriorate, believing that maintaining the ship for another day gives us another opportunity to save those trapped within it. Yet the ship itself remains the source of danger.

Systems of oppression often create precisely this dependency. That is because oppressive systems exercise power over the conditions of life itself. In necropolitical terms, they distribute varied levels of exposure to security, deprivation and death. People living within such systems spend extraordinary energy simply to remain above water. Keeping those violent arrangements alive must not constitute the final ambition of peacebuilding work. The peacebuilding industry, if it were to be helpful at all, should empower the people against the system so that they can one day disrupt this colonial (capitalist, at large) dependence.

None of this requires the abandonment of immediate work to reduce suffering. It requires honesty about the limits of that work and an insistence that reducing suffering does not become a substitute for ending its source. The future of peace rests on a different relationship between peace and justice. Justice is not an optional supplement to peace. That is the significance of Ture’s lesson on liberation as the answer. This essay does not attempt to present a sanitised version of peace on the terms of the oppressed. The peace that the Global South wishes to transpire, is a peace from imperialism, colonialism, and capitalist plunder. In order not to replicate the same violent system we must ask: is our peace liberating?


[1] Roy, Arundhati. Broken republic. Penguin UK, 2013.

[2] Nicola Perugini and Neve Gordon, The Human Right to Dominate (Oxford University Press, 2015), https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199365012.001.0001.

[3] Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem. [2024]ICJ Rep 186.

[4] Byers, Michael. “Still agreeing to disagree: international security and constructive ambiguity.” Journal on the Use of Force and International Law 8, no. 1 (2021): 91-114.

[5] “Colonial Logic Redux: Scholars Comment on Trump and Netanyahu’s Proposal,” Opinio Juris, October 2, 2025, https://opiniojuris.org/2025/10/02/colonial-logic-redux-scholars-comment-on-trump-and-netanyahus-proposal/.

[6] Ture, Kwame. Tell Me Lies (1968).

[7] Donald Trump, ‘Remarks Announcing the White House Middle East Peace Plan With Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel’ (The American Presidency Project, 28 January 2020) <https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/remarks-announcing-the-white-house-middle-east-peace-plan-with-prime-minister-benjamin> .

[8] Nkrumah, Kwame. ‘Neocolonialism: The last stage of imperialism.’ (Thomas Nelson & Sons, London, 1965).

[9] Clausen, Maria-Louise. “Violent Peacemaking: The Violence Within Liberal Peacebuilding.” Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding (2026): 1-19.

[10] Lal Fernando, Jude and Slabodsky, Santiago. Interrogating Religion and Peacebuilding (1st edn, Bloomsbury Publishing 2026) 2.

[11] ibid 2.

[12] Fernando, Jude Lal. “Negotiated peace versus victor’s peace: the geopolitics of peace and conflict in Sri Lanka.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 27, no. 2 (2014): 206-225.

[13] Roy, Arundhati. “Peace & the new corporate liberation theology.” (2004).8

[14] Gramsci, Antonio. “Selections from the prison notebooks.” In The applied theatre reader, pp. 141-142. Routledge, 2020.

[15] Miranda Fricker, “Testimonial Injustice,” in Contemporary Epistemology (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2019), https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119420828.ch10.

[16] Roger Mac Ginty, “Indigenous Peace-Making Versus the Liberal Peace -,” 2008, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0010836708089080?casa_token=98RaPrTuIvwAAAAA:3zQI4LaPMLiJ8M1eRkjKqjk9mKdAmwYpPebQgWF0Xo6wyo7XHAWVtA24DnCjIqw1cZ_JoN7axHG4UQ.

Bana Abu Zuluf is a Palestinian PhD candidate in International Law at Maynooth University, Ireland. She writes on coercive peace, people-to-people dialogue, epistemic oppression, decolonisation, the politics of refusal, and international law's coloniality. Her recent co-authored piece titled Global governance and Palestine: negating the Palestinian right to self-determinationwas published in the Research Handbook on Global Governance (Edward Elgar Publishing).